Benchmark

A benchmark is the standard an investment’s performance is measured against โ€” an index, a peer group, or a target return. In public markets the choice is usually obvious; in alternatives, benchmark selection is half the argument, and reading performance claims starts with reading what they’re compared to.

Benchmarking alternatives โ€” the three approaches

Peer-group quartiles are private markets’ native method: a fund’s IRR, TVPI, and DPI ranked against same-strategy, same-vintage funds in commercial databases. The caveats are known and material โ€” self-reported data, survivorship tilt, and enough provider-to-provider variation that “top quartile” claims deserve the follow-ups: whose data, which vintage convention, as of when? (The industry joke that most funds are top-quartile in some cut exists because it’s arithmetically achievable.) Index comparison and PME answer the opportunity-cost question โ€” did the fund beat public markets on the same cash flows โ€” with index choice as the sensitive input. Absolute and spread targets fit income strategies: credit funds benchmarked against reference rates plus spreads, real estate against property indices (NCREIF family), infrastructure against inflation-plus formulations. For semi-liquid products, the practical complication is smoothness: appraisal-based NAV returns show gentler volatility than any listed benchmark, making risk-adjusted comparisons flatter the private vehicle unless the smoothing is acknowledged. The advisor’s working rules: insist any performance claim names its benchmark and period; prefer net-of-fee comparisons; for private funds, ask for quartile and PME views; and treat a strategy pitched only against benchmarks it structurally can’t lose to as having answered the question already.

PME (Public Market Equivalent) ยท Vintage Year ยท DPI ยท NAV ยท Hurdle Rate

Educational content only; not investment, tax, or legal advice. Consult qualified professionals regarding your specific circumstances.

Featured Partner Video Spotlight

Inland: Built for the long game

Discover Inland

Subscribe to our Newsletter