FINRA Fines Spartan Capital $1 Million, Bars Ex-CCO Kim Monchik Over Pre-IPO Fund Sales
Settlement findings say funds owned by then-CEO John Lowry charged customers approximately $3.25 million in markups that offering documents attributed to a third-party affiliate that acquired nothing.
November 20, 2026

FINRA has censured Spartan Capital Securities, LLC, fined the New York broker-dealer $1,000,000 and ordered it to pay $2,176,398.20 in restitution to customers who bought into 16 private placement offerings tied to pre-IPO companies. The offerings were issued by funds owned and controlled by John Lowry, Spartan's co-founder and its CEO at the time. Kim Monchik, the firm's chief administrative officer and interim chief compliance officer during the period, was barred from associating with any FINRA member firm in all capacities. Lowry was suspended for two years in all capacities and fined $25,000.
The sanctions come through an order accepting an offer of settlement dated October 22, 2026. FINRA's Department of Enforcement filed the complaint on November 24, 2025. Spartan, Lowry and Monchik consented to the findings without admitting or denying the allegations.
Under those findings, Spartan willfully violated Regulation Best Interest and violated FINRA Rules 2111, 3110 and 2010. Monchik violated FINRA Rules 3110 and 2010, and Lowry violated FINRA Rule 2010. FINRA also found that Spartan, Lowry and Monchik recklessly or, at minimum, negligently disseminated false and misleading information to investors, violating Rule 2010 both independently and by acting in contravention of Sections 17(a)(2) and (3) of the Securities Act of 1933.
Between March 2021 and October 2021, Spartan made 344 recommendations with a total principal value of approximately $24 million to 186 customers, 177 of them retail customers and 9 non-retail. Each offering was a separate series of one of three unregistered Delaware limited liability companies, Atlas Fund III, LLC, Atlas Fund IV, LLC and Atlas Fund V, LLC. Lowry owns their manager, Atlas Fund Management LLC, and controls the Atlas entities. Each series used investor money to buy membership interests in SP Venture Fund 8, LLC, a private fund managed by StraightPath Venture Partners, LLC. The StraightPath fund purported to hold shares in a single pre-IPO company that Lowry selected.
Lowry made Spartan the exclusive placement agent and set its fee at 10 percent. Atlas Fund Management also charged a two percent management fee and a 20 percent carried interest on any profit after a liquidity event. The offerings generated approximately $2.4 million in placement fees for Spartan and approximately $480,000 in management fees for Atlas Fund Management.
FINRA found that Lowry's economic interest in the offerings extended beyond those fees to markups. In one example, Lowry negotiated a price per share equivalent of $1450 for interests tied to a company the order calls Company One, and the Atlas entities priced the offering to investors at $1635, $185 per share higher. Across the program, Lowry caused the Atlas Funds to apply markups on 15 of the 16 offerings, ranging from 12.75 percent to 36.4 percent and totaling approximately $3.25 million. The offering documents did not tell investors the price per share equivalent they would receive.
The private placement memoranda told investors the Atlas Funds would not share in any profit on markups a third-party affiliate might charge. Offering supplements said the funds would buy from that affiliate, Iapetus, LLC, at a price above what Iapetus paid. Lowry created Iapetus in February 2021 and is its sole member, which the offering documents did not disclose. Iapetus did not acquire pre-IPO shares for any of the offerings. The Atlas Funds bought directly from the StraightPath fund and applied the markups themselves. FINRA found that the misstatements concealed Lowry's additional compensation and created the false impression that a third party had played a role in sourcing the investments, justifying the markup.
Lowry assigned Monchik to serve as president of the Atlas entities, and beginning in July 2020 she spent approximately 40 percent of her time on them. She was also responsible for Spartan's due diligence on the same offerings. She had no prior experience with pre-IPO offerings, and Spartan had no formal approval process for them.
Monchik first asked the StraightPath fund for documents showing it owned or had access to the pre-IPO shares on March 31, 2021, after Spartan had already sold three of the offerings. She followed up on May 28 and June 9 without a response. By June 15, 2021, Spartan had sold eight of the offerings and the Atlas Funds had sent the StraightPath fund approximately $11.8 million. The documents that arrived that day covered four companies tied to five offerings and did not establish that the fund held any of the shares. Nothing was ever produced for the other three. Spartan representatives then recommended eight new offerings, and the Atlas Funds sent money to the StraightPath fund for them, without Monchik requesting or receiving any proof of ownership.
Her review of StraightPath's manager consisted of very limited internet research and background checks, including a Lexis search on a Georgia entity named StraightPath Ventures LLC that, according to the order, had no connection to the manager. She did not know who owned the manager and did not review its financial statements. She did not document any due diligence on pricing, fees or markups, and completed no due diligence checklists for any of the offerings.
The order states that StraightPath Venture Partners is in receivership as a result of SEC litigation and that the Department of Justice has brought criminal charges against its principals. The SEC has alleged that the manager and its principals charged excessive markups on pre-IPO shares and failed to possess shares they purported to sell. When the FINRA complaint was filed, four of the pre-IPO companies behind the offerings had gone public or experienced a liquidity event.
FINRA also found that Spartan's written policies and procedures contained no provisions to achieve compliance with Regulation Best Interest's care obligation, and that the firm had no written policies to identify, disclose or mitigate conflicts of interest from selling offerings issued by affiliated entities.
Lowry, whom the order describes as Spartan's co-founder and an owner through a holding company, was CEO from 2014 through May 2026. Monchik was chief administrative officer through May 2026. On May 29, 2026, Spartan filed notices terminating both executives' registrations.
Both have earlier FINRA disciplinary records. In October 2024, FINRA's National Adjudicatory Council affirmed a decision that they failed to disclose, or timely disclose, customer arbitrations on their Forms U4. Lowry was suspended for two years, fined $20,000 and statutorily disqualified; Monchik was suspended for two years, fined $10,000 and statutorily disqualified. The order lists an appeal of that decision docketed with the SEC in November 2024. In March 2026, an extended hearing panel found that both failed to respond timely to FINRA requests for documents and information, fining Lowry $50,000 and Monchik $20,000 with two-year suspensions. The order lists an appeal of that case docketed with the National Adjudicatory Council in April 2026.
The suspension and bar take effect on the date of the notice of acceptance of the settlement. Spartan has 120 days from that notice to submit proof of restitution payments. Lowry's fine is due when he re-associates with a member firm or before he applies for relief from a statutory disqualification, whichever comes first. The order states that the restitution does not prevent customers from pursuing their own claims.